In this issue...
Legislative Update
Case Histories: Fleshing Out The Need For Reform
Shaping Opinion In Texas Newspapers
House Civil Practices Committee Plays Important Role In TLR 1997 Reform Package
Statewide Trade Association Endorsements
Local Trade Association Endorsements
Chamber Of Commerce Endorsements
Texans For Lawsuit Reform Legislation
Texans For Lawsuit Reform Staff Members and Positions
Legislative Update
The 75th regular legislative session is past its mid-point, and the focus of the Texans for Lawsuit Reform legislative agenda is on the House Civil Practices Committee. Two bills have already passed the Senate and are pending in Civil Practices: SB 275 pertaining to CPA privity and SB 220 addressing the problem of out-of-state lawsuits. The remaining tort reform bills are being taken up in the House first.
Committee work is the part of the legislative process that involves the closest scrutiny. It is also the part of the process where the public plays the most visible role, providing input and suggestions. TLR has taken an active role in the committee process, recruiting witnesses and providing responses to concerns raised during the hearings.
The House Civil Practices Committee held its first hearing on the TLR legislative agenda on March 11 when it took up HB 1020 by Rep. Junell. This bill gives juries the right to consider the possible negligence of employers that are immune from liability because they provide workers™ compensation to their employees. The legislation is important because it is fundamentally unfair for the negligence of immune employers to be arbitrarily shifted to other defendants.
Almost 100 individuals signed affirmations in support of the bill. These people came from all over Texas to show their enthusiasm for this much-needed reform. TLR recruited attorneys from California and Arizona to testify about the positive impact of similar laws in their states. Several witnesses described actual cases involving their companies that convincingly underscore the need for reform in this area of the law.
On March 18, the committee turned its attention to HB 95 by Rep. Joe Nixon. This bill proposes that Texas move into the mainstream in the area of summary judgment, joining a majority of other states that have procedures in place that closely track the federal approach. This legislation is needed to provide judges with sufficient discretionary authority to dismiss lawsuits that are patently without merit. The premises liability bill, HB 1202 by Rep. Tom Uher, was heard on March 25. TLR worked with a coalition of organizations representing a variety of premises owners---including restaurants, colleges, apartment owners, and retail merchants---to draft a substitute bill to address some of the committee™s concerns that were voiced prior to the hearing. Support for the legislation was forthcoming at the hearing from numerous individuals and associations, including a group of witnesses recruited by TLR who described their case histories.
Hearings on other bills will continue in April. In the meantime, we will continue to work with the committee to address their concerns so the bills can be voted out and considered by the full House of Representatives.
CASE HISTORIES: FLESHING OUT THE NEED FOR REFORM
One of the most effective ways of convincing committee-members that the TLR legislative agenda is reasonable and necessary is by identifying people who have been involved in an abusive lawsuit. These œcase histories provide a snapshot into the ongoing problems with our state™s civil justice system. The following is a case history that was described to the Civil Practices Committee by Bob Rowling, chief executive officer of TRT Holdings, during the March 25 hearing on the premises liability bill.
The plaintiff™s companion was able to escape and he rushed into the hotel to notify security, which was on duty at the time.
The plaintiff sued TRT Holdings, alleging the accident was caused by the company™s failure to provide adequate security, even though there had been no previously reported violent crimes at this hotel, which has on-site security and a well-lit outdoor parking lot.
Although TRT Holdings˜ executive management viewed this case as groundless and wanted to take it to trial, where they expected vindication, the insurance companies decided to settle the case for $4 million the day before the trial was to begin.
Texans for Lawsuit Reform believes the current law affecting premises owners discourages economic investment in urban neighborhoods and discourages property owners from making their facilities available to charitable or non-profit organizations for recreational or educational uses. The committee substitute for HB 1202 will be a significant improvement.
SHAPING OPINION IN TEXAS NEWSPAPERS
Texans for Lawsuit Reform has taken its show on the road with newspaper editorial boards across the state. TLR volunteers and leaders have spent countless hours of their valuable time visiting with these newspapers, not to mention becoming very frequent flyers. Papers visited to date include Amarillo, Austin, Corpus Christi, Dallas, El Paso, Fort Worth, San Antonio, Tyler, the Valley, and Waco.
Visiting with editorial boards gives TLR the opportunity to discuss the seven-point agenda in detail to editors and journalists, and to convince these important messengers that further meaningful tort reform is needed in Texas. The objective is to garner favorable support in newsprint, which legislators watch very closely. This hopefully translates into more support for each of TLR's agenda items by the state representatives and senators in Austin.
Richard Trabulsi, TLR co-founder, who has attended more than seven editorial board meetings since the opening of the legislative session said, œVisiting these newspapers in every corner of the State has been a very effective means of clearly communicating the facts on each of our agenda items. I am extremely appreciative of the talents and time of the many TLR volunteers who have participated in these meetings.
When visiting with editorial boards, it is important to remember these points.
- Keep your presentation within the time-frame allotted by the editorial board, customarily limited to one hour or less. Bear in mind that another group may be waiting to meet with the board when you are finished.
- Be truthful, concise and direct when expressing your viewpoints. If a member of the board does not agree with your position, do not become overly defensive. Instead, re-state the important facts and move on to the next point.
- If you don't know the answer to a question, say that you will get an answer to them as soon as possible, and follow through.
- Provide complete information to leave behind.
- Thank the board for their time and follow up with a brief letter including any additional information you need to relay.
HOUSE CIVIL PRACTICES COMMITTEE PLAYS IMPORTANT ROLE IN TLR 1997 REFORM PACKAGE
In early March, the Texas House of Representatives began hearings on the 1997 tort reform package. The House Civil Practices Committee heard testimony on HB 1020, TLR™s third party liability bill on March 11. This committee activity is perhaps the most important part of the entire process, since the product of their work will be what goes to the entire House.
The following is a list of the members of this crucial committee.
District 23 - Galveston
Democratic Representative Patricia Gray is an attorney. She received her Ba and MEd from Mississippi State University. Her MA was received at The University of Texas at Austin, and her JD from the South Texas College of Law. Born October 2, 1946, she has been a member of the House of Representatives since 1992. Ms. Gray can be reached at 520 20th Street, Galveston, TX 77550, 800/615-2525, and by fax at 409/765-8820. She serves District 23 Galveston County (part) with Senators Galloway and Patterson.
District 150 - Spring
Paul Hilbert is an attorney. He received his MBA from Xavier University and his JD from the South Texas College of Law. Born March 24, 1949, he has been a member of the Texas House of Representatives since 1983. Mr. Hilbert can be reached at 2301 FM 1960 West, Ste. 240, Houston, TX 77068, 713/537-5252. He serves District 150, Harris County (part) as Republican Representative with Senators Lindsay and Whitmire.
District 116 - San Antonio
Leo Alvarado, Jr., the Democratic Representative from San Antonio is an attorney. He received his BA from St. Mary™s University, and his JD from St. Mary™s School of Law. Born April 23, 1939, Alvarado has been a member of the House since 1996. Mr. Alvarado can be reached at 115 Camaron, Suite 200, San Antonio, TX 78205-2492, 210/229-1884, and by fax at 210/223-9464. Mr. Alvarado serves District 116, Bexar County (part) with Senators Luna and Wentworth.
District 128 - Houston
Democratic Representative Bosse is an attorney. He received his BS from Texas A&M University and his JD from the University of Houston, Bates College of Law. Born July 18, 1947, Mr. Bosse has been in the House of Representatives since 1991. He can be reached at 855 Uvalde Rd., #A, Houston TX 77015, 713/453-6336, or by fax at 713/453-5013. Mr. Bosse serves District 128, part of Harris County, with Senators Gallegos, Patterson and Whitmire.
District 142 - Houston
Democratic Representative Dutton is an attorney in Houston. He received his BBA from Texas Southern University and his JD from the TSU Thurgood Marshall School of Law. Born February 17, 1945, Dutton has served in the Texas House of Representatives since 1985. He can be reached at 9111 Eastex Frwy., Suite 336, Houston, TX 77093, 713/692- 9192 or by fax at 713/692-6791. Dutton serves District 142, Harris County (part) with Senators Gallegos, Lindsay, Ellis and Whitmire.
District 93 - Arlington
Mr. Goodman practices law in Arlington where he lives with his wife, Gloria. He received his BBA from texas Christian University and his JD from Baylor University. Born November 2, 1948, Goodman has served the Texas House of Representatives since 1991. Goodman can be reached at 1600 Lamar, Suite 115, Arlington, TX 76011, 817/460-8200 or by fax in Arlington at 817/861-2125 and in Austin at 512/475- 1178. He serves District 93, Tarrant County (part) with Senators Nelson, Harris and West.
District 133 - Houston
Joe Nixon and his wife, Allyson, reside in Houston, where he practices law. Nixon received his BS in Economics from Texas A&M University and his JD at St. Mary™s University. Republican Representative Nixon was born on September 15, 1956 and has served in the House of Representatives since 1995. He serves District 133, Harris County (part) with Senators Gallegos, Lindsay, Ellis and Brown.
District 14 - College Station
William B. Roman, Jr and his wife, Jeanette, live in College Station where he is a physician. Roman received both his BS and BA from The University of Texas, and his MD from the University of Texas Medical Branch. Born January 7, 1925, Roman began his service as Republican Representative just this year. He can be reached at #1 Forest Drive, College Station, TX 77840, 409/774-6309 or by fax at 409/774-9010. Roman serves District 14, Brazos County (part) with Senator Ogden.
District 20 - Winnie
Zbranek and his wife, Angela, live in Winnie where he is both an attorney and a petroleum engineer. Zbranek received his BS from The University of Texas at Austin and his JD from the University of Houston Law Center. Born September 28, 1962, Zbranek has been a member of the Texas House of Representatives since 1993. He can be reached at P.O. Box 2910, Austin, TX 78768, 512/463-0488 or by fax at 512/463-1510. Zbranek serves District 20, Chambers, Hardin and Liberty Counties with Senators Nixon and Galloway.
STATEWIDE TRADE ASSOCIATION ENDORSEMENTS
American Alliance for Rights & Responsibilities
American Collectors Association of Texas
American Society of Civil Engineers
Associated Builders & Contractors of Texas
Associated General Contractors - Texas Building Branch
Association of Chemical Industry of Texas
Automotive Wholesalers of Texas
Consulting Engineers Council of Texas
Independent Bankers Association of Texas
Independent Cattleman™s Association of Texas
Lumbermen™s Association of Texas
Mechanical Contractors Association of Texas
National Federation Independent Businesses
Printing Industries Association of Texas
Rural Rental Housing Association of Texas
Southwest Association
Southwest Meat Association
State Firemen™s and Fire Marshals™ Association of Texas
Texas Ag Industries Association
Texas Aggregates and Concrete Association
Texas Agricultural Cooperative Council
Texas Air Conditioning Contractors Association
Texas and Southwestern Cattle Raisers Association
Texas Apartment Association, Inc.
Texas Association of Builders
Texas Association of Business and Chambers of Commerce
Texas Assn of Homes & Services for the Aging
Texas Association of Life Underwriters
Texas Association of Nurserymen
Texas Association of Realtors
Texas Assn of Residential Care Communities
Texas Association of Wholesale Distributors, Inc.
Texas Chemical Council
Texas Citrus Mutual
Texas Cotton Ginners' Association
Texas Food Industry Association
Texas Forestry Association
Texas Gas Association
Texas Grain & Feed Assn
Texas Health Care Assn
Texas Hospital Association
Texas Hotel and Motel Assn
Texas Housing Association
Texas Independent
Automotive Association
Texas Insurance Professionals
Texas Land Title Association
Texas Lathing & Plastering Contractors
Texas Medical Association
Texas Osteopathic Medical Association
Texas Petroleum Marketers & Convenience Store Association
Texas Physical Therapy Association
Texas Rental Association
Texas Restaurant Association
Texas Risk Retention Association
Texas Seed Trade Association
Texas Sign Manufacturers Association
Texas Society of Architects
Texas Society of Certified Public Accountants
Texas Society of Internal Medicine
Texas Society of Medical Assistants
Texas Society of Professional Engineers
Texas Society of Professional Surveyors
Texas State Florists™ Association
Texas Tire Dealers & Retreaders Association
Texas Waterway Operators Association
Textile Maintenance Association of Texas
LOCAL TRADE ASSOCIATION ENDORSEMENTS
Apartment Association of Greater Dallas
Apartment Association of Southeast Texas
Apartment Association of Tarrant County
Associated Builders and Contractors of Texas/Coastal Bend
Associated Builders and Contractors of Texas/Gulf Coast
Associated Builders and Contractors of Texas/Houston
Associated Builders and Contractors of Texas/South Texas
Associated Builders and Contractors of Texas/Southeast Texas
Assoc General Contractors of America, Inc./Austin
Assoc Builders & Contractors/Mid Coast Chapter
Associated Builders & Contractors/Central Texas Chapter
Associated General Contractors, Inc./Houston
Associated General Contractors/Dallas
Association of Consulting Municipal Engineers of Houston
Austin Apartment Association
Austin Board of Realtors
Bay Area Board of Realtors/Houston
Building Owners and Managers Association of Austin
Building Owners and Managers Association of Houston
Builders Association of Fort Worth & Tarrant County
Chambers County
Consulting Engineers Council of TX, San Antonio Chapter
Corpus Christi Apartment Association
Fort Bend Association of Realtors
Greater Dallas Association of Realtors
Greater Houston Builders Association
Greater Houston Hospital Council
Gulf Coast Grocery Assn. of Texas
Home Builders Association of Southeast Texas
Hotel Association of Tarrant County
Houston Apartment Association
Houston Assoc. of Insurance Agents
Houston Assoc. of Life Underwriters
Houston Association of Realtors
Institute of Real Estate Management/Austin
Institute of Real Estate Management/Houston
Jefferson County Medical Society
Lubbock Apartment Association
Mechanical Contractors Association of Houston
North Texas Oil & Gas Association
Retail Merchants Association/Houston
San Antonio Apartment Association, Inc.
Temple Area Home Builders Association
Texas Capitol Area Builders Association
Texas Society of C.P.A.™s - Houston Chapter
Tritech Regional Council
United Property Owners™ Association/Houston
CHAMBER OF COMMERCE ENDORSEMENTS
Amarillo Chamber of Commerce
Arlington Chamber of Commerce
Athens Chamber of Commerce
Bellville Chamber of Commerce
Belton Area Chamber of Commerce
Bryan-College Station Chamber of Commerce
Canton Texas Chamber of Commerce
Cedar Hill Chamber of Commerce
Denison Area Chamber of Commerce
DeSoto Chamber of Commerce
East End Chamber of Commerce
Eastland Chamber of Commerce
Everman Area Chamber of Commerce
Fort Bend Chamber of Commerce
Fort Worth Chamber of Commerce
Frisco Chamber of Commerce
Giddings Chamber of Commerce
Greater Austin Chamber of Commerce
Greater Dallas Chamber of Commerce
Greater Houston Partnership
Greater Irving-Las Colinas Chamber of Commerce
Greater Killeen Chamber of Commerce
Greater New Braunfels Chamber of Commerce
Greater Orange Area Chamber of Commerce
Greater San Antonio Chamber of Commerce
Greenville Chamber of Commerce
Hallettsville Chamber of Commerce & Agriculture
Harker Heights Chamber of Commerce
Harris County S.E. Economic Development Council
Houston County Chamber of Commerce
Houston Northwest Chamber of Commerce
Humble Area Chamber of Commerce
Longview Partnership
Lufkin-Angelina County Chamber of Commerce
Marble Falls-Lake LBJ Chamber of Commerce
McAllen Chamber of Commerce
Midland Chamber of Commerce
North Houston Association
North Houston Greenspoint Chamber of Commerce
Northeast Tarrant County Chamber of Commerce
Pampa Chamber of Commerce
Pasadena Chamber of Commerce
Plano Chamber of Commerce
Raymondville Chamber of Commerce
Rockdale Chamber of Commerce
San Angelo Chamber of Commerce
Shamrock Chamber of Commerce
South Montgomery County-Woodlands Chamber
South San Antonio Chamber of Commerce
Stratford Chamber of Commerce
Taft Chamber of Commerce
Tomball Area Chamber of Commerce
Weatherford/Parker Economic Council
Westchase Business Council
Wharton Chamber of Commerce
Yoakum Area Chamber of Commerce
TEXANS FOR LAWSUIT REFORM LEGISLATION
| SENATE (as of March 31, 1997) | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| NUMBER | ISSUE | AUTHOR | STATUS |
| SB 220 | Out-of-State | Teel Bivins | Passed by the Senate referred to Civil Practices |
| SB 429 | Third Party | Robert Duncan | referred to Economic Development Committee |
| SB 428 | Premises Liability | Troy Fraser | referred to Economic Development Committee |
| SB 419 | Judgment Reform | Ken Armbrister | referred to Economic Development Committee |
| SB 275 | Privity | David Sibley | Passed by the Senate hearing in Civil Practices (3/25) |
| SB 648 | Summary Judgment | Buster Brown | referred to Economic Development Committee |
| Offer of Settlement | Bill Ratliff | still being drafted | |
| SB 427 | Injured Party Protection Act | Tom Haywood | referred to Economic Development Committee |
| House (as of March 31, 1997) | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| NUMBER | ISSUE | AUTHOR | STATUS |
| HB 7 | Out-of-State | Robert Junell | referred to Civil Practices Committee |
| HB 1020 | Third Party | Robert Junell | heard in Civil Practices Committee Bill pending |
| HB 1202 | Premises Liability | Tom Uher | hearing in Civil Practices Committee (3/25) |
| HB 1022 | Judgment Reform | Paul Hilbert | referred to Civil Practices Committee |
| HB 886 | Privity | Kim Brimer | referred to Civil Practices Committee |
| HB 95 | Summary Judgment | Joe Nixon | heard in Civil Practices Committee Bill pending |
| HB 2985 | Offer of Settlement | Henry Cuellar | referred to Civil Practices Committee |
| HB 1021 | Injured Party Protection Act | Frank Corte | referred to Civil Practices Committee |
Texans For Lawsuit Reform Staff Members and Positions
1200 Post Oak Blvd., Suite 510
Houston, Texas 77056
713/963-9363, 713/963-9787 fax
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
e-mail: MCLinbeck@aol.com
Overall management of staff and administration
ORGANIZATIONAL DIRECTOR (FORMER PAC DIRECTOR)
Special Projects
COMMUNICATIONS DIRECTOR
e-mail: KLOverbeck@aol.com
Manages the speakers bureau; liaison to endorsing trade associations and chambers of commerce
ADMINISTRATIVE ASSISTANT
Information distribution; maintains TLR membership files
1005 Congress Ave., Suite 150
Austin, Texas 78701
512/708-9900, 512/708-0319 fax
LEGISLATIVE DIRECTOR
e-mail: RNFritz@aol.com
Overall management of Austin office; monitors TLR legislation; coordinator of committee presentations
LEGISLATIVE ASSISTANT
e-mail: Luskey@aol.com
Assists with day to day legislative needs; coordinates the publication and distribution of the TLR Advocate
CONSULTANT
e-mail: RGBejma@aol.com
Monitors newspapers and t.v.; coordinates media responses
ADMINISTRATIVE ASSISTANT
Receptionist; assists Randy and Amy with projects as needed
MEMBERSHIP DEVELOPMENT
972/480-8123, 972/480-8785 fax
e-mail: BEVKISH@aol.com
Coordinates key contact program; develops Boards of Governors across the state
