Texans for Lawsuit Reform

Through political action, legal, academic and market research, and grassroots initiatives, TLR fights for common-sense reforms that keep Texas open for business.

  • About TLR
    • Our Mission
    • Our Team
    • Timeline of Reforms
  • Videos
  • Issues
  • Resource Center
    • Special Reports
    • In the News
    • Press Releases
    • The Advocate
    • TLR Blog: For the Record
  • Get Involved
  • Contact
    • Contact Us
    • Invite a TLR Speaker
  • Donate
  • Stay Informed
In the News

Facing complaints of excessive fees, Texas counties release billing records of their opioid lawyers for free

October 10, 2018, Legal Newsline

By: Daniel Fisher

Texas counties that demanded tens of thousands of dollars to provide billing records from outside attorneys representing them in opioid lawsuits have mostly agreed to hand them over for free, after complaints were filed with the Texas Attorney General’s Office alleging the cost estimates were excessive and violated the Texas Public Information Act.

A number of counties initially quoted costs of as much as $750 an hour for outside attorneys to review and redact privileged information from billing statements, which are considered public records under Texas law. The cost demands from counties represented by Simon Greenstone Panatier, a Dallas law firm, were remarkably consistent, with Dallas County, population 2.6 million, and Nacogdoches County, population 66,000, each charging $24,190.

The large cost demands appeared to conflict with the Texas Administrative Code, which caps labor charges for locating, compiling and manipulating data for a public information request at $15 an hour. Time spent to “redact, blackout, or otherwise obscure confidential information” is subject to the same hourly fee cap.

After numerous complaints were filed with the Texas attorney general, several of the counties provided billing records for free. Simon Greenstone declined comment for this story, but earlier said its governmental clients were free to release billing records if they wanted, but would be charged if Simon Greenstone attorneys were required to review the records first.

Travis County, home to the state capital Austin, refused to turn over its billing records, saying they were protected by the attorney-client privilege. Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton’s office rejected that claim almost in its entirety in a Sept. 28 letter, however, saying only entries reflecting “the mental impressions, opinions, conclusions or legal theories” of lawyers are subject to the privilege. Travis County has yet to release records in accordance with the AG’s ruling..

Texas passed a law requiring detailed public disclosure of billing records for outside attorneys after a political scandal erupted over the $3 billion collected by private attorneys in the state’s lawsuit against the tobacco industry. Former Attorney General Dan Morales eventually went to prison for trying to steer $500 million of the fees to a friend, and Texas governments were held to a strict set of rules for hiring and paying outside lawyers. Those rules include record keeping requirements and a two-part test for fees including a “lodestar” calculation based on the actual hours worked.

In disclosures so far, the counties show small teams of lawyers and paralegals have racked up limited hours working for individual counties, while larger teams have worked on “common benefit” projects to be shared by all. Lawyers with Simon Greenstone, for example, recorded just two hours at $200 an hour to draft Parker County’s complaint and only $550 worth of work through Oct. 3. Simon Greenstone’s common expenses, for all its Texas opioid clients, totaled almost 115 hours from September 2017 through August of this year, meanwhile, much of it at partner-level rates of $750 an hour.

The common benefit bill, which will be allocated among all of the law firm’s governmental clients, totaled $64,465 through Aug. 3, according to a Sept. 27 invoice produced under a public records request. Some billing entries were blacked out, while most of the others contain generic statements such as “attorney and staff meeting to discuss pleadings, causes of action, legal research issues, and consulting experts.” The names of expert witnesses hired by the plaintiffs have been blacked out.

One law firm, The Cicala Law Firm, released its records for November 2017 through July of this year for free upon a first request. Cicala represents Webb County and the records show the financial risk assumed by law firms that can’t spread the costs of opioid litigation across a large number of counties. Over that eight-month period Cicala reported more than 1,200 hours worked on the case including more than 50 hours on pleadings and motions.

The outside lawyers representing Texas counties are all working under contingency-fee contracts granting them as much as 35% — the statutory maximum – of any judgment or settlement. The billing records will only be used to compare against those contingency fees. Under Texas law, outside plaintiff lawyers are to be paid the lower of the contingency fee or a lodestar amount calculated by adding up hours billed plus a multiplier of up to four to reflect the risk of taking on the case. The counties aren’t liable for any of the billed amounts unless they obtain a financial recovery.

Follow us on Facebook

Comments Box SVG iconsUsed for the like, share, comment, and reaction icons

Texans for Lawsuit Reform

8 hours ago

Texans for Lawsuit Reform

Texas ports are thriving today, but in the early 2000s, abusive personal injury lawsuits threatened to shut them down. As the Port of Houston begins a long-awaited expansion, read more about the common-sense lawsuit reform in 2007 that saved our state’s shipping industry in this week’s TLR blog, For the Record: bit.ly/3aeTy6n ... See MoreSee Less

Learn More

Play
View on Facebook
·Share

Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Linked InShare by Email

  • Likes: 0
  • Shares: 1
  • Comments: 0

Comment on Facebook

Texans for Lawsuit Reform

1 day ago

Texans for Lawsuit Reform

Wishing everyone a very happy Fourth of July! ... See MoreSee Less

Wishing everyone a very happy Fourth of July!
View on Facebook
·Share

Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Linked InShare by Email

  • Likes: 5
  • Shares: 0
  • Comments: 1

Comment on Facebook

Happy Independence Day America Today we celebrate our Republic 🇺🇸

Texans for Lawsuit Reform

4 days ago

Texans for Lawsuit Reform

In case you missed it: Specialized business courts like the Delaware Court of Chancery can be an important addition to a state’s economic foundation. These courts quickly and expertly handle complex business litigation, freeing up other courts to handle other types of cases. Read and share: bit.ly/3y7zwnI ... See MoreSee Less

Link thumbnail

Making Business Our Business

bit.ly

Much has been written about Elon Musk—eccentric billionaire, CEO of some of the most innovative companies in the world and… future owner of Twitter? While the nuances of this deal are daily fodder...
View on Facebook
·Share

Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Linked InShare by Email

  • Likes: 0
  • Shares: 0
  • Comments: 0

Comment on Facebook


Follow us on Twitter

lawsuitreform avatarTLR@lawsuitreform·
5h 1544441042120089600

Sign up for the TLR Weekly News Roundup to receive a daily digest of headlines & news stories about #lawsuitreform from Texas & around the country!

Sign up for the TLR Weekly News Roundup!

Please use the form below to receive a daily digest of TLR Clips - headlines and news stories about lawsuit reform from Texas and around the country.

bit.ly

Reply on Twitter 1544441042120089600Retweet on Twitter 1544441042120089600Like on Twitter 15444410421200896001Twitter 1544441042120089600
lawsuitreform avatarTLR@lawsuitreform·
8h 1544407069297614851

Texas ports are thriving, but in the early 2000s, abusive lawsuits threatened to shut them down. Read more about the common-sense reform that saved our state’s shipping industry in this week’s TLR blog, For the Record: https://bit.ly/3aeTy6n

Twitter feed video.
Image for the Tweet beginning: Texas ports are thriving, but
Reply on Twitter 1544407069297614851Retweet on Twitter 15444070692976148512Like on Twitter 1544407069297614851Twitter 1544407069297614851
lawsuitreform avatarTLR@lawsuitreform·
4 Jul 1543988532720566273

Wishing everyone a very happy #4thOfJuly!

Twitter feed video.
Image for the Tweet beginning: Wishing everyone a very happy
Reply on Twitter 1543988532720566273Retweet on Twitter 1543988532720566273Like on Twitter 15439885327205662732Twitter 1543988532720566273

Texans for Lawsuit Reform
1701 Brun Street
Houston, Texas 77019

Ph. 713-963-9363
  • About TLR
  • Our Mission
  • Our Team
  • Timeline of Reforms
  • Videos
  • Issues
  • Resource Center
  • For the Record
  • Special Reports
  • In the News
  • Press Releases
  • Invite a TLR Speaker
  • Get Involved
  • Invite a TLR Speaker
  • Donate
  • Stay Informed
  • Contact TLR

Copyright © 2022 · Texans for Lawsuit Reform. All rights reserved. | Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2022 · Texans for Lawsuit Reform.
All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy