Texans for Lawsuit Reform

Through political action, legal, academic and market research, and grassroots initiatives, TLR fights for common-sense reforms that keep Texas open for business.

  • About TLR
    • Our Mission
    • Our Team
    • Timeline of Reforms
  • Videos
  • Issues
  • Resource Center
    • Special Reports
    • In the News
    • Press Releases
    • The Advocate
    • TLR Blog: For the Record
  • Get Involved
  • Contact
    • Contact Us
    • Invite a TLR Speaker
  • Donate
  • Stay Informed
In the News

Texas Plaintiffs Benefit from Democratic Judicial Sweep, New Study Shows

Texas Lawyer, September 24, 2019

By Angela Morris

Many Texas judges say the “R” or “D” after their names do not impact their rulings on the bench.

But a new study shows that when Democrats swept appellate benches in the Lone Star State’s major metro areas, there was a huge impact on civil rulings—which helped plaintiffs.

The study comes just as the state is launching a new commission to study nonpartisan methods of judicial selection in Texas. However, similar pushes in the past to put partisanship aside in judicial elections have failed.

“We were surprised by how dramatic the difference was in consumer cases after the new Democratic judges took the bench,” said Haynes and Boone partner Kent Rutter, who conducted the study with Haynes and Boone associate Natasha Breaux. “The 2018 elections brought the Houston, Dallas and Austin courts in line with the trend we are seeing statewide: The courts of appeal are showing much greater deference to jury verdicts, and plaintiffs naturally benefit from that trend.”

Many appeals come up from trial court cases in which plaintiffs won a judgment, he explained, which means that appellate rulings that uphold jury verdicts often benefit those plaintiffs.

Rutter and Breaux, both from Houston, studied civil rulings by the state’s 14 intermediate appellate courts between September 2018 and August 2019, and released findings Monday in a presentation, “Reasons for Reversal in the Texas Courts of Appeals.”

“I think the study does show that political affiliation does make a difference,” Rutter said.

Consider rulings in tort and consumer protection cases: From September to December 2018, when the Houston, Dallas and Austin appellate courts were still all-Republican, appellate rulings reversed plaintiffs’ trial court wins 39% of the time, while the courts only reversed defendants’ victories 5% of the time.

When Republicans were swept out of those courts in the November 2018 election, and Democrats replaced them in January 2019, reversal rates in tort and consumer protection cases changed drastically. From January to August, the appellate courts reversed plaintiffs’ victories 17% of the time and reversed defendants’ wins 18% of the time.

Rutter noted the numbers are unable to reveal to what extent partisanship affected decisions, and there are other factors that could have impacted outcomes.

“One explanation for the shift could be that the departing judges were clearing the most difficult cases from their dockets in the final months of 2018,” Rutter noted. “It may be premature to draw long term conclusions from the new justices’ first eight months on the bench.”

Breaux added that partisanship aside, some of the statistical change may be attributed to the fact that these justices were brand new.

“In general, new judges are more likely to be deferential to trial court rulings. No new judge, however experienced, can have experience with all the different types of cases that the courts of appeal see,” Breaux said.

Another finding from the study may surprise trial lawyers, she said, noting that she’s heard litigators complain about how juries are selected, what evidence was allowed or barred, or how juries resolved conflicting testimony.

“The courts of appeal don’t reverse jury verdicts for the reasons that they expect, Breaux explained. “When the courts of appeal do reverse after a jury trial, about two-thirds of the time, it’s because the case never should have gone to the jury in the first place.”

Follow us on Facebook

Comments Box SVG iconsUsed for the like, share, comment, and reaction icons

Texans for Lawsuit Reform

8 hours ago

Texans for Lawsuit Reform

Texas ports are thriving today, but in the early 2000s, abusive personal injury lawsuits threatened to shut them down. As the Port of Houston begins a long-awaited expansion, read more about the common-sense lawsuit reform in 2007 that saved our state’s shipping industry in this week’s TLR blog, For the Record: bit.ly/3aeTy6n ... See MoreSee Less

Learn More

Play
View on Facebook
·Share

Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Linked InShare by Email

  • Likes: 1
  • Shares: 2
  • Comments: 0

Comment on Facebook

Texans for Lawsuit Reform

1 day ago

Texans for Lawsuit Reform

Wishing everyone a very happy Fourth of July! ... See MoreSee Less

Wishing everyone a very happy Fourth of July!
View on Facebook
·Share

Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Linked InShare by Email

  • Likes: 5
  • Shares: 0
  • Comments: 1

Comment on Facebook

Happy Independence Day America Today we celebrate our Republic 🇺🇸

Texans for Lawsuit Reform

4 days ago

Texans for Lawsuit Reform

In case you missed it: Specialized business courts like the Delaware Court of Chancery can be an important addition to a state’s economic foundation. These courts quickly and expertly handle complex business litigation, freeing up other courts to handle other types of cases. Read and share: bit.ly/3y7zwnI ... See MoreSee Less

Link thumbnail

Making Business Our Business

bit.ly

Much has been written about Elon Musk—eccentric billionaire, CEO of some of the most innovative companies in the world and… future owner of Twitter? While the nuances of this deal are daily fodder...
View on Facebook
·Share

Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Linked InShare by Email

  • Likes: 0
  • Shares: 0
  • Comments: 0

Comment on Facebook


Follow us on Twitter

lawsuitreform avatarTLR@lawsuitreform·
6h 1544441042120089600

Sign up for the TLR Weekly News Roundup to receive a daily digest of headlines & news stories about #lawsuitreform from Texas & around the country!

Sign up for the TLR Weekly News Roundup!

Please use the form below to receive a daily digest of TLR Clips - headlines and news stories about lawsuit reform from Texas and around the country.

bit.ly

Reply on Twitter 1544441042120089600Retweet on Twitter 1544441042120089600Like on Twitter 15444410421200896001Twitter 1544441042120089600
lawsuitreform avatarTLR@lawsuitreform·
8h 1544407069297614851

Texas ports are thriving, but in the early 2000s, abusive lawsuits threatened to shut them down. Read more about the common-sense reform that saved our state’s shipping industry in this week’s TLR blog, For the Record: https://bit.ly/3aeTy6n

Twitter feed video.
Image for the Tweet beginning: Texas ports are thriving, but
Reply on Twitter 1544407069297614851Retweet on Twitter 15444070692976148512Like on Twitter 1544407069297614851Twitter 1544407069297614851
lawsuitreform avatarTLR@lawsuitreform·
4 Jul 1543988532720566273

Wishing everyone a very happy #4thOfJuly!

Twitter feed video.
Image for the Tweet beginning: Wishing everyone a very happy
Reply on Twitter 1543988532720566273Retweet on Twitter 1543988532720566273Like on Twitter 15439885327205662732Twitter 1543988532720566273

Texans for Lawsuit Reform
1701 Brun Street
Houston, Texas 77019

Ph. 713-963-9363
  • About TLR
  • Our Mission
  • Our Team
  • Timeline of Reforms
  • Videos
  • Issues
  • Resource Center
  • For the Record
  • Special Reports
  • In the News
  • Press Releases
  • Invite a TLR Speaker
  • Get Involved
  • Invite a TLR Speaker
  • Donate
  • Stay Informed
  • Contact TLR

Copyright © 2022 · Texans for Lawsuit Reform. All rights reserved. | Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2022 · Texans for Lawsuit Reform.
All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy